Takers

There is an absurd email going around that contends that there are more people on welfare than are working in 11 States. Nonsense.
____________

If you've gotten the "Death Spiral" email that's apparently been arriving in many inboxes, here's the verdict from two major, nonpartisan fact checkers:

It is NOT true, as the email claims, that in 11 states there are more people on welfare than there are working.

The debunkers: both PolitiFact.com and FactCheck.org.

First, some background:

A Forbes column talked about 11 "death spiral" states that are "danger spots for investors" because of rising taxes, "deteriorating state finances and an exodus of employers." The states: Alabama, California, Hawaii, Illinois, Kentucky, Maine, Mississippi, New Mexico, New York, Ohio and South Carolina.

"Two factors determine whether a state makes this elite list of fiscal hellholes," Forbes' William Baldwin wrote. "The first is whether it has more takers than makers. A taker is someone who draws money from the government, as an employee, pensioner or welfare recipient. A maker is someone gainfully employed in the private sector."

Baldwin, who tells FactCheck that "what he reported and what the email says 'are not the same thing at all,' " does not claim in his column that the states have more people on welfare than are working. And as PolitiFact points out:

Baldwin included people who are working, for state and local governments, in his "takers" column. He also put government pensioners, who can certainly make the case that they worked for their earnings, in the takers column.

The only people Baldwin counted as being on welfare are Medicaid recipients.

"None of the 11 states on his list has more Medicaid recipients than workers," FactCheck writes. "Also, none of the states has more recipients [than workers] of other kinds of 'welfare,' such as TANF (Temporary Assistance for Needy Families) or food stamps (officially known as the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program)."

"By either a broad definition of welfare or a narrow one," PolitiFact concludes, experts say it's "false and even 'extreme' " to say that the states have more people on welfare than are working. So, it gives the email its harshest rating: "Pants on Fire!"


http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2013/01/11/169153282/spike-that-email-about-welfare-and-work-fact-checkers-say-its-not-true



___________________

But Mr. Baldwin's column is not accurate either.  The graphic and text below from his article.



"The first is whether it has more takers than makers. A taker is someone who draws money from the government, as an employee, pensioner or welfare recipient." forbes.com/sites/baldwin/2015/12/22/which-are-death-spiral-states/#611a4f686840


But the table below shows the total State and local employment by State. His "taker" State of California doesn't have an unusually high number of employees.



StateState / LocalState / Local FTE per
FTE Full Time Employment10,000 Residents
Alabama138,758286
Alaska28,858392
Arizona128,803191
Arkansas71,048239
California883,408228
Colorado129,933243
Connecticut75,782211
Delaware23,721253
Florida424,961213
Georgia217,872216
Hawaii37,583265
Idaho37,040227
Illinois264,211205
Indiana131,762200
Iowa73,089235
Kansas79,087272
Kentucky97,173220
Louisiana132,113284
Maine28,649215
Maryland133,946224
Massachusetts139,429206
Michigan182,391184
Minnesota121,740223
Mississippi91,036304
Missouri145,324240
Montana26,872263
Nebraska54,527290
Nevada53,690189
New Hampshire27,843210
New Jersey205,211230
New Mexico55,987268
New York623,162316
North Carolina258,933260
North Dakota20,404276
Ohio262,318226
Oklahoma89,707231
Oregon95,290240
Pennsylvania257,459201
Rhode Island21,981208
South Carolina123,451256
South Dakota19,318226
Tennessee154,624236
Texas562,650209
Utah63,422215
Vermont14,680234
Virginia188,522226
Washington183,248259
West Virginia44,645241
Wisconsin114,565199
Wyoming26,073446
Average243

http://www.governing.com/gov-data/public-workforce-salaries/states-most-government-workers-public-employees-by-job-type.html


California and Illinois have major financial problems and poor governance. But not because they have a very high ratio of government employees.

And I would enjoy seeing Mr Baldwin explain to a Chicago Cop why he is a "taker"!  I would pay to see that. Perhaps we could set up a charity event pay for TV event where Baldwin explains his "taker" theory to some of Chicago's finest. 




No comments:

Post a Comment

This blog was created to Plan the Planet. It is a work in progress - please click here if you wish to propose changes or additions or ask q...